Rebel177's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Gauntlet - Medley]

Great by half!

I loved the beginning of the song, the pure simplicity of the piece along with the harmony of the other what seems to be a guitar was flawless!

However, i did not really favor the beat of the song from 40:00 up.

4/5 7/10

Stage3-1 responds:

I know how you feel. The two pieces are kind of opposite. But some people like the start, some like the end, some like it all. It's hard to please everyone. Thanks for the review.

[Project NR13 "intro"]

Just about crap...

No music whatsoever, it's just a voice over.
If you made the voice over then put this in voice acting.

Z-Tone responds:

please listen to the whole piece as there is music in there i made...
and no i didnt make the voice its a sample from the bible

[S.i.C.K.]

This is Absolutely Horrid!

This is enough to make babies cry and ears bleed,what kind of person would make this,and what kind of idiot would submit this?

td6d responds:

Well actually more persons made this possible and Im the idiot who uploaded it.
Still got a pretty decent score so I think Ill leave it here, tho I do think it fitted better in the metal section..

[Super Duper Happy]

Not too happy.

It's an ok song but it feels like a loop,it's that repetitive.
Good songs have structure,such as the adding one additional instrument as
the song moves on. it just keeps the same pattern,it's good but not great.

You would be a master at loops though.

i like it,respect your effort,and like the genre giving you a 5 / 8 of 10

cHunter responds:

Trust me, once it gets lyrics it won't be as bad. Thanks for listening and reviewing though.

:D

[Runescape {^}-{Alix1}-{^}]

sounds like it

pretty good but there was more background to the music ,and who hasn't played rs before xD

9 for effort and reenactment -1 for t being runescape D:

alix1 responds:

Lol. thanks for the review! If i played WoW i would probably have WoW music on here instead. the music in WoW is sooooo coool!

[- The Raid -]

Perfect,the name says it all.

Your music is an inspiration,Truly staying along the lines of
actually classical.I find it hard to say i like this more or less than dungeon of
deceit. This is the quality i expect from you now.But looking at your songs,it seems to be a standard.I can see your music making it to the best of all time list already.

SinJim responds:

Thanks for the comments! I'm glad you enjoyed this.

~SinJim

[Mad World Electronic Mix]

what did you do?

it sounds like you took the original song and added crap that sound horrible
and then you looped the horrible sounds,it's like your killing your cat and recording it,and then even looped it into the song adding nothing new.
New ELEMENTS is a basic of every song! do you like to listen to the same 4 second tone a day? i sure as hell don't!

But i do give at least 4/10 for effort. so cheers...

Blizzaine responds:

Lol.

I recorded live piano. Not the original song, added a vocoded voice, addded a nice breakbeat.

And back on 10/21/2008 I was rather newby to music, check out my new stuff. This song is currently being redone as a dance song.

[- Dungeon of Deceit -]

Beauty in itself...

I wish i could rate higher than 10.
Very good piece,now i expect more like this to come.

SinJim responds:

Thanks for the review! If you like this one, you'll probably like my other song, "The Raid." I'll PM in a bit with a link. Hopefully I can come up with some more stuff along these lines.

~SinJim

[Rise of a new King]

Inspiration,Fantastic!

I can just imagine a castle where a new king is being crowned,he sits on his throne,then walks to the crowd gathered outside after walking down a row of his
friends and they all cheer.

I think i will mike a hl2 machinima with this as the base.

DukeLukeProd responds:

Yeah I had an Aragorn-ish person and a Minas Tirith-ish setting in mind ^^
Machinima.. is that some kind of mod?
Thanks for the review :)

[MH16: An Ultimate Journey]

has feeling

i can tell you put your actual feelings into this and worked hard on it.
i dont like the genre of the song but hey,we need more people like you making songs. 4 and a 7

FairSquare responds:

Thanks for the review!